Background
The appellant was issued a caste certificate in 1984 as belonging to the “Tokre Koli” Scheduled Tribe. On that basis, he was appointed as Junior Engineer (Civil) with the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai in 1994 and later promoted. After losing the original certificate, he obtained a fresh one in 2000.
In 2008, his caste claim was referred for verification. The Police Vigilance Cell relied on old family records showing the caste of his paternal ancestors as “Koli”, “Hindu Koli” or “Hindu Suryawanshi Koli”. After prolonged proceedings, the Scheduled Tribe Certificate Scrutiny Committee, by order dated 27.07.2020, invalidated the caste certificate and cancelled/confiscated it.
The Bombay High Court, by judgment dated 15.09.2020, upheld the Scrutiny Committee’s order, holding that pre-constitutional family records carried high probative value and that the appellant had been given sufficient opportunity.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
The Court found no error in the conclusions of the Scrutiny Committee and the High Court regarding the invalidation of the “Tokre Koli” claim. The appeal was therefore dismissed on merits insofar as the caste status is concerned.
However, noting the equities of the case, the Court exercised its power under Article 142 of the Constitution to do complete justice:
- The appellant had served for more than three decades (1994 to 30.06.2025).
- He continued in service under the Supreme Court’s interim order and retired on attaining superannuation.
- He filed an affidavit stating that he has no children and that no family member has availed any benefit on the basis of the invalidated certificate.
Directions
- The service rendered from 21.10.1994 till retirement on 30.06.2025 is protected only for the limited purpose of computation and release of retiral and pensionary benefits.
- The protection does not amount to validation or recognition of the “Tokre Koli” claim.
- Neither the appellant nor any family member shall be entitled to any future benefit on the basis of the invalidated certificate.
- Retiral and pensionary benefits shall be processed and released within six months.
Significance
The judgment reaffirms the high evidentiary value of pre-Independence family records in caste/tribe verification cases while simultaneously demonstrating the Court’s willingness to protect long-serving employees from the harshest consequences of invalidation through the equitable jurisdiction under Article 142, especially where no future generational benefits are involved.
Case Details:
- Case Title: Shirish Pandharinath Patil v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
- Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 12938 of 2020
- Citation: 2026 INSC 949
- Bench: Justices Aravind Kumar & Vipul M. Pancholi
- Date: 03 September 2026
Click HERE for full Judgment.
Lawcutor 